On Thanksgiving morning, 1994, three months into my ministry at First Parish in Plymouth, the Interfaith Thanksgiving Service was being held.  The church was filled with 500 people and we were awaiting the arrival of the Pilgrim Progress to begin the service.  The United American Indian of New England (UAINE) were marching past Town Square towards the church when they were told they could not come into the church. UAINE objected to being told this. This was, afterall, a public service.  The Police on duty asked me, as the representative of First Parish and the Clergy Association, what to do. Given it was a service open to the public I said they were welcome to come in.  They entered the church and filled all the empty seats at the front of the church where the Pilgrim Progress was to sit.  The members of UAINE made it clear they were not going to move to make room for the group.  At that point, not being sure what to do in what I feared could have turned into something ugly, Richard Serkey suggested to me that I offer UAINE three minutes to speak if they would be willing to move after that so the service could begin.  This suggestion diffused a very tense situation. At that point Mahtowin Munro spoke about the genocide of indigenous people, the consistent breaking of treaties, and the mythology surrounding the Pilgrims and subsequent settlers.  After Ms. Monro finished speaking, the members of UAINE got up and left the service.

In the following years, First Parish, other congregations, the Interfaith Clergy Association along with Town leaders worked towards finding a peaceful settlement that acknowledged and balanced the concerns of the town and UAINE. Sadly, it still came to a head with the violence on Thanksgiving, 1997.  The agreement in question today by the Board of Selectmen is a result of open and honest discussions among many parties following that sad day.

During those years I had frequent contact with Moonanum James and Mahtowin Monro.  I always found them to be honest and honorable people.  While we did not always agree in our discussions, we treated each other respectfully and thoughtfully. To sit with them and truly listen is to hear the depth of their pain and anger is deeply uncomfortable as a descendant of those settlers.  While we cannot change the past, we can acknowledge it and express sorrow that it happened. That and we can work to change the systemic injustices that have allowed the descendants of the settlers to thrive while others suffer still.

With all this background, the actions of the Select Board echo the past history of broken treaties that were written in good faith by all involved parties at the time.  While I do not speak for UAINE, I am certain this feels like more of the same.  History repeats itself.  I can fully understand why there has been no response to Olly DeMacedo’s offer of a stage and paying for insurance.  It is a generous offer.  However, it misses the point completely.  The issue is the broken word of the Town of Plymouth, showing that once again a signed agreement between the Indians and government is worthless.  I am not surprised that UAINE has been silent.

And while I am eternally grateful to Richard Serkey for the sage advice he gave me 32 years ago, I disagree with his statement that UAINE has picked the scab and won’t let it heal.  It seems to me the Select Board has ripped the scab off to the detriment of all.  We have had 28 years of peace without incident.  But as a wise person once said to me, “Just because something is successful doesn’t mean we want it to continue.”

– Michael R. Leduc

Share this story

Thank you to our sponsors. Become a sponsor.