A group of Plymouth residents has accused the Select Board of violating the state’s open-meeting law in its handling of a new apartment complex proposed by influential developer Rick Vayo.

Four separate complaints have been filed since the Select Board voted 4-1 on Sept. 29 to help support Vayo’s proposal to build a controversial 392-unit apartment complex in West Plymouth.

The critics argue the agenda item for the meeting was vague and did not provide enough information to give the public adequate notice – a claim disputed by Select Board Chair Deb Iaquinto.

The Select Board advertised the hearing on its public agenda four days before the meeting at which it heard Vayo and voted to send a letter to the state supporting the project.

“120 Carver Road – Memorandum of Agreement and Letter of Support for Affordable Housing Development / Comprehensive Permit Rick Vayo, 120 Carver LLC *Vote Anticipated,” the agenda item read.

Critics argue the posting violated the law’s spirit by not specifying the project was for 392 apartments and would be developed under the state’s 40B law, which allows developers to circumvent many local regulations as long as 25% of the units are deemed affordable.

“I think that the notice was vague,” said Wynn Gerhard, one of the four residents who filed a complaint. “If it said something like 40B project and 392 units, that would have gotten people’s attention.”

Under the open meeting law, the complaint must first be filed with the Select Board, which has 14 business days to respond to the complaints filed Oct. 26, 28, and 29. If the board does not respond in a timely fashion, the residents can appeal to the Massachusetts Attorney General’s office, which will determine if a violation occurred.

The residents are asking the Select Board to reverse its support for the project and hold an open meeting to discuss its impact.

Iaquinto said the agenda stated Vayo was seeking a “comprehensive permit.”

“That would suggest to anyone knowledgeable about it that it was a 40B,” Iaquinto told the Independent.

Town counsel Kate McKay told the Select Board last week that a notice is considered sufficiently specific “when a reasonable member of the public could read the topic and understand the anticipated nature of the discussion.”

McKay said she does not believe that the posting was in violation of the open meeting law.

The light area on this image shows the location of the proposed Darby Farms development.

Iaquinto said the board and town staff were able to negotiate an agreement with Vayo to mitigate the impact of the development on traffic, water, police, fire, and emergency medical services.

Vayo agreed to pay $1.2 million for the West Plymouth water system, $600,000 to match a state grant to hire eight firefighters, $500,000 for “improvements to the Cranberry Crescent sewer pump station,” and $200,000 for a new recreational space in the area.

“Those kinds of negotiations, you don’t typically have those in public,” Iaquinto told the Independent. “There was nothing nefarious about it at all. We put it on the agenda.”

Vayo told the Independent he worked diligently with the Select Board to come up with a project that could in one fell swoop prevent unfriendly 40B projects from coming to town. Once the town has more than 10 percent of its housing counting as affordable, it can limit further development. The state 40B law allows developers to circumvent many local regulations. Vayo’s project, on the other hand, comes with major concessions to the town. 

“They wanted infrastructure help,” Vayo said of the board members. “We had to take quite a bit of time to make that work. That was a lot of the negotiation and quite frankly, they were very tough, tougher than I thought they would be.” 

Vayo developed the recently opened Drew Hotel, the latest in a long list of projects that began more than a dozen years ago with the transformation of the former National Guard Armory on Court Street into condominiums and includes converting the former Registry of Deeds on Russell Street into 19 condos; turning the Governor Bradford Hotel on Water Street into a harbor front hub with apartments, the La Baia restaurant, and Vitamin Sea Brewery, an apartment complex at the former Mount Pleasant School on Whiting Street, and Plimoth General Store and Bamp’s Toy Vault. 

He has also held out for desirable tenants for his properties on Main and Court Streets, favoring restaurants such as the newly relocated Gillis Family Tavern over honky-tonk bars.  

Iaquinto said technically, the open meeting law was not violated because the agenda was posted four days before the Select Board meeting.

Iaquinto said the board complied with another open meeting law requirement that no more than two members of the board can meet in private. She and board member Kevin Canty were the two members who negotiated with Vayo, who also met individually with the other three board members to explain his project.

The board voted 4-1 to send a letter of support for Vayo’s project to the state Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities. Member Richard Quintal was the lone dissenter, citing concerns about traffic, water, and sewers.

Planning Board member Frank Mand told the Independent the Select Board did not mention the Vayo project at its meeting in West Plymouth Sept. 15.

Iaquinto said the Select Board could not disclose that it was negotiating the project with Vayo at that meeting because she, Canty, and town staff were still working out the details at that point.

The project will be reviewed by the Plymouth Zoning Board of Appeals, which will hold public hearings.

But Gerhard said that won’t be for months, and the Select Board’s support is likely to have an influence on the Zoning Board of Appeals.

“This is a fast track,” Gerhard said. “We just feel like we were shut out of any ability to have a say.”

Fred Thys can be reached at fred@plymouthindependent.org

Share this story

Thank you to our sponsors. Become a sponsor.