The Select Board meeting of Nov. 17 attracted dozens of Plymouth residents opposed to the Board’s recent decision to unilaterally renege on an agreement reached in 1998 between the town and the United American Indians of New England (UAINE). That agreement included a commitment to provide a stage for speakers on Cole’s Hill during the annual Day of Mourning, and the Board decided, in executive session, to suspend that commitment. Many meeting attendees spoke during public comment to express their disappointment, anger and shame.

The Day of Mourning is a sacred gathering of Indigenous Peoples from across North America. Thousands have come to Plymouth annually since 1970 to publicly mourn centuries of historic injustices and suffering. For me personally, the town’s support to the Day of Mourning represents the very best of Plymouth.

The decision to unilaterally break the 1998 agreement is an insult to all Indigenous Peoples. It joins the countless treaties negotiated in good faith between native tribes and he US government for more than 250 years, treaties that were ultimately ignored and cast aside. The Select Board’s decision represents yet another broken treaty.

This is a plea to the Select Board to revisit their decision and correct the error. Their decision was not only wrong morally, there are clear financial risks. The decision can hurt local businesses and town coffers by damaging Plymouth’s reputation as a tourist destination.  

UAINE is already challenging the decision in court and extended public litigation will further erode the reputation of America’s Hometown. It will expose, yet again, the strained relationships between the town and Native Americans. It will, once again, put the lie to the myths that Plymouth markets to attract the tens of thousands of free spending tourists annually.

I am asking Select Board members to please revisit your decision. It is not too late and time is short. You owe it to all Indigenous Peoples across our country. You owe it to the people of Plymouth. You owe it to yourselves to do the right thing.

– Peter Matlon

Share this story

Thank you to our sponsors. Become a sponsor.