One of the most gut-wrenching votes I have cast as a Select Board member came this week.
The Board was asked to review the decision of our Dog Hearing Officer regarding a dog that had repeatedly demonstrated dangerous behavior. We were presented with evidence that the dog had attacked another dog, attacked at least three civilians, including a neighbor on their own property, and had been used as a weapon against two Plymouth police officers while they were carrying out their duties.
The animal was also unlicensed and unvaccinated, creating an additional risk to both people and other animals. The owner failed to comply with an earlier order from the Dog Hearing Officer, which led the Town to take custody of the animal. Even while in the Town’s care, the dog continued to exhibit extreme aggression.
The owner’s repeated failure to comply with lawful orders to restrain and control the animal ultimately left the Town with very limited options. Under Massachusetts law, rehoming the dog was not an option. Our choice was to return the dog to its owner or affirm the Hearing Officer’s order.
I love dogs. I also believe they are a reflection of the people who raise and handle them. When properly trained and cared for, they are loyal companions and valued members of our families. When they are not, they can pose a serious threat to people, property, and other animals.
I took no satisfaction in affirming euthanasia. But my responsibility is not to make the emotionally easier decision. My responsibility is to protect the people of Plymouth. When the evidence demonstrates a clear and ongoing danger to public safety, refusing to act is itself a decision. Based on the facts before us, I could not, in good conscience, vote to return this animal to its owner and risk another attack.
I know some will focus on my exchange with Selectman Keohan after the vote. They are free to do so. My focus remains protecting the residents of Plymouth from an animal that repeatedly demonstrated its capacity to inflict serious harm.
– David Golden
Golden is a member of the Select Board.