I strongly disagree with several of the assertions made by Ms. Wynn Gerhard in her recent letter to the Plymouth Independent.
First, the September 29 Select Board meeting was properly noticed in accordance with the requirements of the Open Meeting Law. In fact, the agenda was quite specific. The item was titled “120 Carver Road – Memorandum of Agreement and Letter of Support for Affordable Housing Development / Comprehensive Permit.” It identified the developer by name, Rick Vayo of 120 Carver LLC, and explicitly stated “Vote Anticipated.”
The agenda identified the property address, the developer, the proposed action involving affordable housing and a comprehensive permit, and the fact that the Board anticipated taking a vote. This was not some vaguely worded agenda item that concealed what was being considered.
Residents are certainly entitled to disagree with the Board’s actions, but disagreement with an outcome does not mean the process was improper.
Ms. Gerhard makes clear that she lives very close to the proposed development and is concerned about its impact on her neighborhood. Those concerns are legitimate. But there is an important distinction between a procedural objection and dissatisfaction with a housing proposal someone does not want near their home. The Open Meeting Law is not a mechanism for overturning decisions simply because residents dislike the outcome.
Second, I strongly disagree with her characterization of Selectman Canty’s remarks as intimidating, disrespectful, or demeaning.
Mr. Canty was addressing an uncomfortable but critically important reality: Plymouth is becoming increasingly unaffordable for the very people who grew up here. Young families, working people, and even the children of long-time residents are being priced out of their own hometown.
Those of us fortunate enough to already own homes have every right to raise concerns about development. But owning a home in Plymouth does not give us the exclusive right to decide who else gets the opportunity to live here.
Ms. Gerhard emphasizes that she and her neighbors have lived in West Plymouth for a long time. I respect that. But longevity of residency does not confer greater ownership of Plymouth’s future. The people who cannot afford to live here deserve consideration, too, even if they aren’t sitting in the meeting room.
And while Ms. Gerhard may have felt uncomfortable hearing Mr. Canty’s perspective, disagreement is not intimidation. Elected officials are entitled to express their views just as residents are entitled to express theirs.
We cannot continue lamenting that our children and grandchildren cannot afford to live in Plymouth while treating every proposal for additional housing as an unacceptable intrusion into an established neighborhood.
Public participation matters. But those of us entrusted with making decisions on behalf of this community have a responsibility to consider more than the interests of those who already live here. We must consider the next generation of Plymouth residents, too.
– David Golden
Golden is a member of the Plymouth Select Board

